Skip to Content

A Closer Look: No Tax on Everything—The Tax Mess Trump Has Left Us

My name is Bob Lord. I am the Senior Vice President for Tax Policy at Patriotic Millionaires and an Associate Fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies. Before my time as a tax justice advocate, I practiced tax law for 35 years, with a short break to run for Congress in 2008. My ultimately unsuccessful congressional run was inspired by America’s metastasizing inequality and concentration of wealth. And what better way to help in the fight against our worsening oligarchy than to use my experience in tax law to help unrig our tax code, right?

If you’re a longtime reader of the Patriotic Millionaires’ “Closer Look” newsletter, you may remember me from some of the past pieces I’ve guest authored. I’ve written about Charles Littlejohn, the former IRS contractor who leaked the income tax records of some of the nation’s wealthiest individuals; the real reason we want to tax the rich; and my thoughts on Professor Michael J. Graetz’s brilliant book about the antitax movement in America, The Power to Destroy: How the Antitax Movement Hijacked America.

I wanted to take the pen for this week’s Closer Look to share a piece that I wrote for my Substack last month in support of the Working Americans’ Tax Cut Act. I designed this legislation as the second part of the Patriotic Millionaires’ legislative platform, The MONEY Agenda. It was introduced in March 2026 in the Senate by Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen and in the House by Representative Don Beyer (VA-08). Essentially, it would create an exemption for federal income taxes up to the cost of living for low- and middle-income Americans and shift the responsibility for the resultant lost revenues onto taxpayers with incomes over $1 million.

As I explain in my piece, passage of the Working Americans’ Tax Cut Act is critical to the integrity—and the survival—of our federal tax system. Trump and other cynical politicians (in both parties) are seizing on the plight of millions of Americans who can’t afford basic living costs to pander to voters through a slew of “no tax on” proposals akin to Trump’s “no tax on tips.” The result will be a tax system so arbitrary and unfair that the voluntary compliance by taxpayers, which undergirds our tax system, will break down.

My full piece is below. I hope you enjoy it, and be sure to subscribe to my Substack at this link if you’d like to follow my work.

****

No Tax on Everything: The Tax Mess Trump Has Left Us

A tale of two couples:

Barney and Betty are both 66. Betty works as a hostess at a local restaurant. She makes $15,000 in hourly pay, plus another $25,000 in tips. Barney owns an interest in his family’s business, organized as a Subchapter S corporation, from which his annual income is $50,000. Over the holidays, Barney works long hours at a local big box store. He makes $10,000, $2,500 of which is the premium for overtime.

At tax time, Barney and Betty report $100,000 of adjusted gross income. In computing their taxable income, they take deductions of $25,000 for Betty’s tips, $12,000 in deductions for seniors, a $10,000 qualified business income deduction for Barney’s income from the family business, a $2,500 deduction for Barney’s overtime pay, and a standard deduction of $35,500, leaving them with taxable income of $15,000 and a federal income tax bill liability of $1,500.

Fred and Wilma are both 64. Wilma no longer works. Fred makes $100,000 per year as an accountant with a local firm. Although he works long hours during tax season, he is not paid overtime because of his base compensation and position, which includes managerial duties. At tax time, Fred and Wilma report $100,000 of adjusted gross income. They take a standard deduction of $32,200, leaving them with taxable income of $67,800 and a federal income tax liability of $7,640.

These are, of course, concocted examples. But they show how tax policy in the US under Trump has returned to the stone age. There are couples with tax pictures virtually identical to Barney and Betty’s and other couples with tax pictures virtually identical to Fred and Wilma’s. Do they ever compare their respective situations? Do they question the Swiss cheese tax code we have courtesy of two Trump tax bills?

Could it get worse? Absolutely. As Brian Faler at Politico reported, members of Congress have a slew of new “no tax on” proposals ready to campaign on. No Tax on Boat Loan Interest? Yep. No Taxes on Utility Bills? Absolutely, and it’s bipartisan no less! I spoke to a senior congressional staffer a few months ago who was just giddy about all the “no tax on” proposals his office hoped to include in a 2029 budget reconciliation bill.

The “no tax on” provisions currently in the tax code are set to expire after 2028. Will they be extended? Of course they will. As I commented to Politico, if you do away with no tax on tips, you can kiss the state of Nevada goodbye. And imagine how this will play in the other swing states in 2028. “No tax on auto workers” sure will sound sweet in Michigan. And if you want to carry Georgia, you damn well better sign on to “no tax on peanut farm workers.” By the time we get to the 2032 campaign, the pandering will be stripped of all pretense and we’ll be hearing “no tax on Pennsylvanians.”

How problematic is this from a tax policy perspective? Huge. The federal income tax system depends on voluntary compliance. The system must make sense to taxpayers for them to voluntarily comply. If you’re Fred or Wilma, would our tax system still make sense to you? Hardly.

How, then, do we rein this craziness in? We start by identifying the source of the problem. As gimmicky as provisions like no tax on tips are, and even though they benefit only a tiny percentage of workers, they address a need millions of Americans feel and millions more Americans understand. When people hear “tipped worker,” they don’t picture the blackjack dealer at the Venetian making $150,000 a year. They don’t even picture a worker like Betty, who together with her husband enjoys a comfortable income. They picture the struggling unmarried server at their local Denny’s slinging dishes for $35,000. And they understand well she doesn’t have enough income before federal income tax, let alone after, to pay her basic living expenses.

Now, consider struggling non-tipped workers and their reaction to no tax on tips. Do they think their tipped counterparts are getting an unfair break like the ultrarich get on their lightly-taxed investment gains? Or do they think that they should have their income tax burdens reduced as well, and that the rich should be required to pay more?

Asking those questions, of course, answers them, and shines a light on the real problem: The federal income tax is fundamentally flawed at both ends of the income spectrum. At the lower end, incomes not even sufficient to cover basic living expenses are subject to federal income tax. At the upper end, marginal rates top out at a fraction of the country’s highest income levels. Doctors making in the high six figures face the same marginal tax rate as CEOs making 50 times that much.

The only path out of this mess is to rebalance our income tax structure. The Working Americans’ Tax Cut Act, a bill introduced by Sen. Chris Van Hollen and Rep. Don Beyer, would accomplish that rebalancing. Their bill provides an exemption from federal income tax for income up to the basic cost of living, with a progressively smaller income tax reduction for those with incomes just above the basic cost of living. At the same time, the bill imposes a surtax on income in excess of $1 million, and larger surtaxes on income above $2 million and $5 million.

If the Working Americans’ Tax Cut Act becomes law, the ghastly “no tax on” provisions could be allowed to expire. The great majority of tipped workers, like that struggling server at Denny’s, won’t care, since they’d pay no federal income tax either way. A handful of taxpayers would still benefit from no tax on tips. But nobody will waste political capital on a tax break for affluent blackjack dealers.

Members of Congress face a choice. They can continue their vote-pandering through “no tax on” proposals. Or they can address the glaring structural flaws in the federal income tax and, in doing so, perhaps save our tax system and our democracy.

Let’s hope they make the right choice. Stone age tax policy won’t end well for any of us.

A Closer Look: It’s Living Wage Week!

A Closer Look: It’s Living Wage Week!

It’s Living Wage Week, and to mark the occasion, we are excited to shine a spotlight on the importance of living wages by co-writing a piece with Michelle Murray, the CEO of Living Wage for Us, to emphasize why living wages matter and also how many avenues there are to achieve this goal for both workers and employers.

November 9, 2026

A Closer Look: Yes, the economy is stupid, but voters aren’t.

A Closer Look: Yes, the economy is stupid, but voters aren’t.

It’s hard to believe, but we’re six days away from Election Day. And while pundits are obsessing over polls and prediction markets to get a sense of how things will shake out next Tuesday, we know the one thing that is the real bellwether for this election cycle. Reporting from The Washington Post found that 60% of families in battleground districts across the country can’t afford basic essentials.

October 29, 2026

A Closer Look: Debunking All Myths about Prop 40

A Closer Look: Debunking All Myths about Prop 40

As promised, we wanted to send out a second Closer Look this week to share additional key information about Prop 40 before Election Day. Prop 40 could become the first tax on billionaires in history, and in the words of Six Nobel Prize-winning economists, could “…kickstart a movement to tax ultra-high-net-worth individuals in other states—and eventually at the federal level and in other countries.”

October 23, 2026

A Closer Look: 40 for 40

A Closer Look: 40 for 40

We’ve made a lot of noise about California’s Proposition 40 over the last few months. But today, with just two weeks to go until the election, we’ve turned up the volume big time and released two products—an open letter and a poll—in support of the one-time tax on Golden State billionaires.

October 20, 2026